On the Incompleteness of the Coelacanth Fossil Record

  • publication
  • 08-07-2025

Yuan, Z., Cavin, L., Song, H.. Fossil Studies 2025, 3, 10. https://doi.org/10.3390/fossils3030010

This study conducted a spatiotemporal review of the coelacanth fossil record and explored its distribution and diversity patterns. Coelacanth research can be divided into two distinct periods: the first period, which is based solely on the fossil record, and the second period following the discovery of extant taxa, significantly stimulating research interest. The distribution and research intensity of coelacanth fossils exhibit marked spatial heterogeneity, with Europe and North America being the most extensively studied regions. In contrast, Asia, South America, and Oceania offer substantial potential for future research. Temporally, the coelacanth fossil record also demonstrates significant variation across geological periods, revealing three diversity peaks in the Middle Devonian, Early Triassic, and Late Jurassic, with the Early Triassic peak exhibiting the highest diversity. With the exception of the Late Devonian, Carboniferous, and Late Cretaceous, most periods remain understudied, particularly the Permian, Early Jurassic, and Middle Jurassic, where the record is notably scarce. Integrating the fossil record with phylogenetic analyses enables more robust estimations of coelacanth diversity patterns through deep time. The diversity peak observed in the Middle Devonian is consistent with early burst models of diversification, whereas the Early and Middle Triassic peaks are considered robust, and the Late Jurassic peak may be influenced by taphonomic biases. The low population abundance and limited diversity of coelacanths reduce the number of specimens available for fossilization. The absence of a Cenozoic coelacanth fossil record may be linked to their moderately deep-sea habitat. Future research should prioritize addressing gaps in the fossil record, particularly in Africa, Asia, and Latin America; employing multiple metrics to mitigate sampling biases; and integrating a broader range of taxa into phylogenetic analyses. In contrast to the widespread distribution of the fossil record, extant coelacanths exhibit a restricted distribution, underscoring the urgent need to increase conservation efforts.

see on external website